Adding Mia Goth to the ever-expanding list of A-level actors for his next movie, The Odyssey, is another casting genius by Christopher Nolan. The fan reactions are inevitably funny, and the internet is burning.

As we stare at the ever-increasing cast list for Christopher Nolan’s upcoming adaptation of The Odyssey, we can’t help but think of the whole thing as a giant puzzle. How does this list of names—including Matt Damon,